(Requested)

Keith x Reader x Matt

______________________________________________________________________________________________

Matt and I were sitting in the common room, sharing milkshakes and chatting away happily.

"...and then I said, 'No, like real tears. Like Native American tears,'" Matt joked, grinning. I giggled and smiled at the boy in front of me.

"You impish dork," I sighed, rolling my eyes playfully.

"I'm your dork," he flirted. I scoffed.

"Not yet, Matthew," I shot back, smirking. "But maybe one day." He smiled in anticipation.

"I can't wait, doll." I heard Pidge snort from the other side of the room.

"Oh, get a separate room you two!" she teased. I blushed and smirked at Pidge.

"Maybe."

__

The news hit me like a ton of bricks. Keith was coming back from the Blade. I sat down, shaking. Matt put his hand on my shoulder.

"Hey, (Y/N), are you alright?" the sandy-haired male asked me, looking at me with worried eyes. I turned to him, eyes starting to water.

"Matt... Keith, he's coming back," I whispered, happiness tinted in my voice. "Oh my god..."

"He is?" Matt replied, surprise tinting his voice. I nodded excitedly.

"In an hour, he'll be back..." I muttered, cupping my cheeks.

"Yeah, he'll be back and I'll be alone again..." Matt whispered, leaving my side. I was confused and reached out to grab his arm.

"Matt... Don't go," I pleaded.

"You're already excited for Keith to come back. I don't think you'll need me with you.

"C'mon," I sighed, pulling him in for a hug. He lurched forwards and tackled me in an embrace. I let my back hit the cushions of the couch, Matt on top of me.

"I don't want you to leave."

"I won't, you dork."

__

(Third Person)

Keith slid the door open to find (Y/N) and Matt Holt on the couch together, playing video games. The young woman cheered as she won the battle against the tanned guy sitting next to her.

"Eat it, Holt!" she whooped, raising her fists into the air. Keith stifled a little smile and started to walk towards her.

(Reader's POV)

I heard footsteps and was met with my ex-boyfriend, Keith. I gasped and ran into his arms, sobbing. We broke up before he went to join the Blade, since we both knew LDR couples never worked out, and it was too dangerous for us to continue.

"Keith, oh my god, you're here!" I cried, embracing him tightly. He let out a long breath.

"I missed you so much, babe," he mumbled, burying his face in the crook of my neck.

"I thought you would never come back, jackass!" I muttered angrily, resting my chin on his shoulder. Matt cleared his throat and we separated almost immediately.

"Oh, Matt Holt, right?" Keith said, voice laced with uncertainty. The male across him nodded and held out his hand.

"Nice to finally meet you, Keith." The ravenette shook his hand and let the corners of his mouth curve a bit.

"Same to you."

__

"Okay, you can only choose one of us, (Y/N)," Matt said, placing his hands on mine. I winced and sighed.

"Matt, why?" I replied, slipping my hands out from under his.

"I can tell he still has leftover feelings for you!" he said loudly, clenching his fists. I thought for a moment and bit my bottom lip.

"Matt..."

(Choose:)

Matt

> Keith

(Player selected successfully!)

"Look, Matt, I don't want to hurt you," I said, my voice strained. "I love you, but only as a friend. Please, understand."

The boy that sat in front of me looked down, dismayed.

"I really thought you would choose me..." he mumbled. "But it's okay..." I kissed his head and clasped his hands.

"Can we still be friends?" I asked gingerly. He nodded, as fragile as glass.

"But if he breaks you, just a tiny bit, don't hesitate to come to me, okay?" he joked. I giggled, tears in my eyes.

"Yeah. Thank you, Matt."

__

I sat on my bed, smiling with Keith as I ruffled his hair, admiring the outgrown mullet and purple streak on his left cheek.

"You've changed a lot, Keith," I commented. "Your jawline looks like it could cut glass." He smirked and kissed my hand.

"It could always cut glass." I giggled and continued to chat with him for the rest of the evening until we fell asleep in each other's arms. But that night, another heartbroken Matt shared his bed with himself, warming the comforter alone.

__

I woke up to meet soft breaths along my neck.

"Good morning, Keith," I whispered, kissing his head. He smiled gently and kissed my collarbone, sliding his hands up and down my sides, making me shiver.

"Good morning (Y/N)," he replied huskily. I bit my bottom lip, tempted to bring his face closer to mine and press my lips against his soft ones like we did all the time. He kissed me before I could kiss him. I pressed my lips softly against his, kissing back. He crawled on top of me and started to gingerly kiss down to my neck and jaw.

"Mmm, Keith~" I groaned. He smirked and sucked on a patch of skin until a small purple bruise formed when he broke away, panting. Keith licked his lips and grinned.

"Can you be mine again, princess?" he whispered in my ear, nipping the lobe. I moaned and nodded slowly.

"Of course, Keith," I sighed in ecstasy, his hands creeping up to cup my breasts. The Korean male chuckled and licked a thin strip on the side of my neck.

"I love you."

(Choose:)

> Matt

Keith

(Player selected successfully!)

"Matt, I want to be with you," I said slowly, smiling more and more. His eyes widened and he hooted, knocking me down.

"(Y/N)!" he cried out happily. "My new girlfriend!" My eyes sparkled as I leaned in for a kiss, pressing my lips against his for a short and chaste kiss. It took him by surprise, I'm guessing since he gasped and almost fainted on the couch.

"Matt!" I giggled, "Get up you big dummy!" He sprung up and bounced up and down.

"Ah!" he squealed. "I'm so happy!" His arms wrapped around me and hugged me tightly, snuggling into my chest.

"G-Get off, you pervert!" I shouted playfully, shoving him off. He laughed giddily and planted his face into my back.

We spent the rest of the afternoon whispering sweet nothings to each other and nuzzling on the couch.

"I love you, doll."

"I love you too, Matt."